Should you hire movers or rent a truck? Renting a truck usually costs less up front, but you do all the lifting, driving and planning yourself. Hiring movers costs more but saves time, protects your back and puts trained hands on heavy furniture and stairs. Many people choose a middle option: rent the truck themselves and hire a moving crew only for loading and unloading. This guide from Collegiate Movers, a Roanoke moving company since 1999, compares all three so you can pick the right one for your move.
Want a quote to compare? Call (540) 992-1414, Monday to Saturday from 7am to 7pm, or request a free quote online.
Key Takeaways
- DIY truck rental works best for small moves, short distances, ground-floor homes and people with several strong helpers.
- Full-service movers make sense for larger homes, stairs, heavy furniture, tight schedules and anyone who cannot lift safely.
- The hybrid option, a rental truck plus labor-only movers, cuts the heavy lifting while you handle the driving.
- Compare the full cost, not just the rental rate: fuel, mileage, equipment, insurance, time off work and the risk of injury or damage.
Movers vs. Rental Truck: Side-by-Side Comparison
| Rent a truck (DIY) | Truck + labor-only movers | Full-service movers | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who lifts and carries | You and your helpers | Moving crew | Moving crew |
| Who drives the truck | You | You | Moving company |
| Furniture padding and equipment | Rent or buy yourself | Crew usually brings pads and dollies | Included with the crew |
| Loading the truck safely | Your responsibility | Done by trained movers | Done by trained movers |
| Time and effort for you | Highest | Medium | Lowest |
| Up-front cost | Lowest | Medium | Highest |
| Best for | Studio or small apartment, short move | Budget moves with heavy items | Family homes, stairs, busy schedules |
The Real Cost of Renting a Moving Truck
The daily rental rate is only part of a DIY move. When you compare it with a moving company quote, add up everything a DIY move really takes:
- Mileage and fuel. Many rental trucks charge per mile, and large trucks use a lot of fuel.
- Equipment. Dollies, furniture pads and straps are usually extra.
- Coverage. Your car insurance may not cover a rental truck, so rental companies offer their own protection plans.
- Packing supplies. Boxes, tape and wrap add up quickly for a full house.
- Time off work. A DIY move often takes a full weekend or more, plus a day to return the truck.
- Help from friends. Pizza and gratitude are cheap, but friends are not always available, experienced or careful with heavy pieces.
- Injury and damage. Back strains, dropped dressers and scraped door frames are the most common hidden costs of moving yourself.

When Is It Worth Hiring Movers?
Hiring professional movers is usually worth it when any of these apply:
- You are moving a house, not a room. Two or more bedrooms usually means more furniture than a few friends can move in a day.
- There are stairs. Basements, second floors, apartment stairwells and steep front steps are where most injuries and damage happen.
- You own heavy or valuable items. Pianos, safes, solid wood dressers, glass tables and large TVs need the right equipment. See our guide on how to move a piano.
- Your schedule is tight. Closing dates, lease end dates and work start dates do not leave room for a move that runs long.
- You cannot lift safely. Seniors, people with injuries and parents of young children are often better off letting a crew handle it.
- The move is long distance. Driving a large truck across several states is tiring and stressful. Our long distance movers handle the whole trip.
When Does Renting a Truck Make Sense?
A DIY move can be the right call when:
- You are moving a studio or one-bedroom apartment with little heavy furniture
- Both homes are on the ground floor or have elevators
- The move is short, across town or to a nearby town
- You have two or three strong, reliable helpers for the whole day
- You are comfortable driving and parking a large truck
The Hybrid Move: Rent the Truck, Hire the Muscle
If the budget is tight but the furniture is heavy, the hybrid move is often the best value. You rent the truck or a portable container, and a moving crew does the part that is hardest on your body: carrying furniture down stairs, loading the truck so nothing shifts, and unloading at the other end.
Collegiate Movers’ moving labor service is built for exactly this. The crew brings pads, straps and dollies, wraps your furniture and stacks the truck tight and secure. You drive, and another crew or the same crew can meet you at the new home to unload.

How to Decide: 5 Questions to Ask Yourself
- How many rooms of furniture am I moving? More than two bedrooms points toward movers.
- How many stairs are at each home? Every flight adds risk and time.
- Who will help, and for how long? Be honest about how many reliable helpers you really have.
- What is my time worth? Compare the hours a DIY move will take with what you would earn or lose in that time.
- What would it cost to replace or repair my most valuable furniture? If the answer is a lot, let trained movers handle it.
How to Compare a Moving Company Quote With a Truck Rental
- Get a written quote. A good moving company lists the crew, the services and how the price is calculated.
- Price out the full DIY move. Add mileage, fuel, equipment, coverage and supplies to the rental rate.
- Check the mover’s credentials. Look up the USDOT number on the FMCSA Protect Your Move site and read recent reviews.
- Ask what is not included. Know how stairs, long carries, packing and heavy items are handled before you book.
Our moving cost guide explains how local quotes work in the Roanoke Valley.
Movers vs. Truck Rental Questions
Is it cheaper to rent a truck or hire movers?
Renting a truck is usually cheaper up front, especially for small, short moves. Once you add mileage, fuel, equipment, coverage and time off work, the gap is often smaller than it looks, and hiring movers removes the risk of injury and damage.
Is it worth hiring movers for a local move?
For a home with two or more bedrooms, stairs or heavy furniture, yes. A trained crew finishes faster and protects your furniture and home. Local moves with Collegiate Movers in the Roanoke Valley start from $350.
What are labor-only movers?
Labor-only movers load and unload a truck or container that you rent and drive yourself. Collegiate Movers offers moving labor in Roanoke and the surrounding area, with pads, straps and dollies included with the crew.
Can I rent a truck and hire movers just to load it?
Yes. This hybrid move is popular because it saves money while keeping the heavy lifting off your back. Collegiate Movers can load your rental truck or portable container and unload it at your new home.
How many people do I need to move a house myself?
For a two or three bedroom home, plan on at least three or four strong adults for a full day, plus someone to watch children and pets. Heavy pieces like pianos and safes need specialized equipment.
What size moving truck do I need?
As a rough guide, a small truck or van suits a studio, a mid-size truck suits a one or two bedroom apartment, and the largest rental trucks suit a three bedroom house or more. If in doubt, choose the larger size so you only make one trip.
How do I find a reliable moving company in Roanoke, VA?
Look for a licensed and insured company with a USDOT number, recent reviews and a written quote. Collegiate Movers has served the Roanoke Valley since 1999 with USDOT number 861003.
Get a Quote From Collegiate Movers
Whether you want a full-service move or just a crew to load your rental truck, Collegiate Movers can help. We are licensed and insured with USDOT number 861003 and have moved families and businesses in the Roanoke Valley since 1999. Call (540) 992-1414, Monday to Saturday from 7am to 7pm, or request your free quote online. See our local moving company page for full-service moves.
